Cheerleader Kait and her friend Isabella Jones decide on a horror film for their double date that night. Kait asks if Isabella's boyfriend Robby Echo ever gets fear boners. She confesses that her boyfriend, Codey Steele, definitely does. They agree that they're definitely watching a movie tonight.

Sure enough, as Kait snuggles with Codey, he gets a hardon at the first jump scare. Kait puts a blanket over Codey's lap and take care of him with a handie while Isabella tries to get the same from Robby. When Robby doesn't spring a stiffie, Kait invites Isabella to get hands on with Codey.

When Robby inevitably figures out what's going on, he confronts the other three. They coax him into swapping Isabella and Kait, creating a foursome. It's immediately hot as the two guys make out with their new partners. Then Isabella gets on her knees to suck Codey off while Kait does the same for Robby.

Then it's time for the real deal. Codey takes a seat so Isabella can mount him in reverse cowgirl. Meanwhile, Kait hikes up her miniskirt and kneels on the couch so Robby can dick her down from behind. The girls change it up so Isabella can enjoy Robby's fuck stick as she lays on the couch while Kait rides Codey in cowgirl.

Things get even hotter as Isabella turns around and lets Codey bang her in doggy so she can make out with Isabella. Another partner swap leaves Kait on her back with her tongue fondling Isabella's clit as Robby dives nice and deep between Kait's thighs. Meanwhile, Codey gives it to Isabella from behind for some double delight.

The guys can't hold on any longer. Pulling out, Codey blows his load all over Kait's face as she looks up at him. Isabella strokes Robby off, helping him pop so she can lick the tip clean.